"School terror lesson to kill Australians" : Is there educative potential here or just poor professional judgement?

Jon Austin's picture

 A teacher in Western Australia has apparently set an assignment for her 15-year-old students wherein they had to plan a lethal terrorist attack.  Further details, as reported through the mass media, are available here  
Unsurprisingly in an environment where a major swing to conservative politics has just been recorded in last week-end's federal election, and where a major contributing factor in this was the conservatives tapping xenophobic, racist and similar sentiments buried not too far below the surface in large sectors of this country, this classroom event has generated a storm of outrage. Some reports have an explanation of the teacher's motives as trying to have students understand something of belief-driven actions of those who are demonised.  I haven't seen anything by way of a comment by the teacher herself, and it would be highly unlikely that her State government employer would allow her to make such a comment to the media anyway.
While there can be little doubt that there is valuable pedagogical material somewhere in the scenario provided by the teacher, I don't think this is a particularly sensible way to go about trying to generate understanding of the position of the Other.  It seems to me that genuinely critical educative work has to be based in a position of concern for the well-being of humanity in the first place.  Asking students to plan to kill as many people as possible in their assignment work flies directly in the face of that basic premise.  Further, critical work is surely about building ties of solidarity and understanding within and across communities of difference - I don't think this will do that is quite the ways the teacher might have hoped.  A major part of critically engaging communities through teaching must be to pick the arenas and the topics that will help build commonalities, not shatter them.  

Login or register to tag items

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Ilhan Kucukaydin's picture

Something wrong!

Thanks Jon for sharing this. Wow! I believe I cannot even stretch this assignment to fit in any pedagogical frame. I think there is something else going on there, beyond pedagogy..

Pedagody of Love for Humanity

"Dialogue cannot exist, however, in the absence of a profound love for the world and for men."
Paulo Freire
To walk the pain we feel, I guess if we can access the teacher, give him/her Pedagogy of the Oppressed to breathe the truth within education and other books or articles that s/he can locate herself in the current educational context we're all living.
 

kheggart's picture

I agree it's pretty scary

I agree it's pretty scary stuff, but I can honestly say that I'm not particularly surprised. I've taught English for a while now, and I've definitely noticed an increase in students' writing about such matters - and teacher's setting tasks related to these kind of issues. A lot of teachers in this case are trying to tap into student's contexts and understandings of the world around them, as well as the fact that many students spend more and more of their time in increasingly violent and realistic online worlds - like Call of Duty, Modern Warfare 2, which requires students to take part in a terrorist attack on an airport.
Obviously, I'm not condoning any such behaviour, and I, too, was put in mind of Freire's comments regarding the importance of love for humanity. What I am doing is questioning how we might begin to act against such a lack of empathy.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Tags for "School terror lesson to kill Australians" : Is there educative potential here or just poor professional judgement?